CYP2D6 Genotyping Fails to Predict Effectiveness of Tamoxifen

TON - April 2012, Vol 5, No 3 published on April 27, 2012 in In the News
Alice Goodman

According to 2 large breast cancer trials, CYP2D6 genotyping was not predictive of the effectiveness of tamoxifen in postmenopausal women. Thus, the results of these studies are not generalizable to premenopausal women. 

CYP2D6 genotyping has been a focus of research interest, but studies have been inconclusive as to the value of testing. In theory, certain CYP2D6 genotypes and phenotypes would be associated with breast cancer outcomes on treatment with tamoxifen; that is, tamoxifen would be less effective inpoor and intermediate metabolizers of endoxifen (a metabolite of tamoxifen) and more effective in extensive metabolizers of endoxifen. 

The 2 studies—ATAC and BIG 1-98—were published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute (JNCI) online on March 6, 2012.
 
ATAC was a prospective clinical trial that compared effectiveness and safety of the aromatase inhibitor anastrozole versus tamoxifen in postmenopausal women with hormone receptor–positive early-stage breast cancer. Tumor samples from 1203 women were genotyped for CYP2D6. At a median follow-up of 10 years, no significant associations were found in the tamoxifen-treated group between the CYP2D6 genotype for poor metabolizers versus extensive metabolizers for distant recurrence or for any recurrence. As might be expected, no associations were found between the CYP2D6 genotype and recurrence in the patients who received anastrozole. 
 
BIG 1-98 randomized postmenopausal women with hormone-sensitive, operable, invasive breast cancer to 5 years of treatment with tamoxifen monotherapy versus letrozole monotherapy. The findings were similar to those of ATAC, with no significant association found between CYP2D6 metabolism phenotypes and breast cancer–free interval in women treated with tamoxifen.  
 
The authors of BIG 1-98 also studied new-onset or worsening hot flushes during the first 2 years of tamoxifen therapy. They wrote, the results “suggest that CYP2D6 testing is not justified to determine whether tamoxifen should be given  to postmenopausal women, nor to withhold treatment with an aromatase inhibitor. The presence or absence of hot flushes should not be used in the clinical setting to estimate tamoxifen efficacy.”
 
In an accompanying editorial in the same issue of JNCI, Catherine M. Kelly, MD, and Kathleen I. Pritchard, MD, wrote: “The fact that these two studies confirm each other suggests that this matter has likely been laid to rest.” They noted that the findings suggest that the vast industry of CYP2D genotype testing was premature, that patients underwent additional and unnecessary tests and charges related to genotyping, and that therapy was adjusted according to genotyping test results without firm evidence.
 
Both editorial writers wrote that the lessons learned from these 2 large trials include the need for large confirmatory studies of therapeutic agents and biomarkers. Results of ATAC and BIG 1-98 illustrate that laboratory observations that raise hypotheses must be independently validated in order to guide clinical practice.
Related Items
Patient-Reported Outcomes Influence Radiation Guidelines
Alice Goodman
TON - September 2017, Vol 10, No 5 published on September 10, 2017 in Conference Correspondent
Hair Loss Seen in 1 of 3 Women with Breast Cancer Receiving Endocrine Therapy
Alice Goodman
TON - September 2017, Vol 10, No 5 published on September 10, 2017 in Conference Correspondent
Adverse Events Associated with Checkpoint Inhibitors
Alice Goodman
TON - September 2017, Vol 10, No 5 published on September 10, 2017 in Adverse Effects
Overcoming Cultural Barriers to Screening Access
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Conference Correspondent
CDK4/CDK6 Inhibitors Show Promise in Advanced Postmenopausal Breast Cancer
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Breast Cancer
Tackling Obesity and Excess Weight in Patients with Cancer
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Conference Correspondent
Turning the Tables: An Oncology Nurse Becomes a Patient with Cancer
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Conference Correspondent
CAR T-Cell Therapy: What to Expect
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Conference Correspondent
Managing Radiation-Related Side Effects in Patients with Human Papillomavirus–Associated Oral Cancer
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Adverse Effects
Nurse Navigation Program Improves Access and Satisfaction with Cancer Care
Alice Goodman
TON - July 2017, Vol 10, No 4 published on July 6, 2017 in Best Practices
Last modified: May 21, 2015